Your task : Each one of you must vote for either the novel or the film and then, you are expected to defend your choice using your best English in 5 sentences
In the Chapter 5, I prefer the film because we learn that Willy Wonka runs a contest for going visit his factory, in image, it's more funny !!! Whereas in the book, we learn by the newspaper ... it's boring. And in the book, Charlie seems to have less chance.
For this chapter, I prefer the book because Willy Wonka explains in details the organization of his worldwide lottery. He insists about the prize and the visit that he'll give to the five lucky winners. He will show them all the magie and secrets of his factory. In the film, we only see the headline of the EVENING BULLETIN. We have less information in the film than the book.
In the book Charlie's family learnt Mr Wonka decided to allow five children to visit his factory by reading a newspaper,whereas in the film they learnt it on TV. So Charlie's family is poorer in the book than in the film.I prefer the book because we don't espect him to find a golden!The book more incredible!
To mind, the book is better than the film in chapter 5. I find that the Golden Tickets, in the book, are better introducted than the film. In the book, we get the family's opinion whereas in the film, we only see Charlie. But, in the film, Grandpa Joe is shown as a worker in the chcolate factory by Tim Burton, I believe this is interesting.
In this chapter,I prefer the book because they are more details about the challenge. I like the challenge because anybody can win and I like it,but rich families are luckier than poor families because they can't afford many chocolate bars.
In the book ,Dahl insists on the fact that :Charliecan win a golden ticket ,whereas ,in the film we see that everyone wants a golden ticket .In the book ,Carlie finds the golden ticket the first time whereas in the film , he finds the golden ticket the third time .
Chapter 5: I prefer the book because it is more explanatory.It is fabulous that five lucky childr(en are going to visit the mysterious chocolate factory.It's umbelievable that the chocolayte factory didn't open for the last ten years.The other children have much more chance to win than Charlie.For Grandpa Joe mister Willy Wonka is a magician.
I think that the book really, beggins in the chapter five, because it is in this chapter that we learn that five lucky winners, can visit the biggest chocolate factory in the world! but charlie's grandpa said that charlie hasn't got a chance because he has got juste on chocolate bar a years (for his birthday). I think too the capter five is less long that chapter eight or one. Willy Wonka, the confectionnary's genius said that one of five winners can be his heir...of course, I prefer the book because in the film it's a very little passage
12 commentaires:
In the Chapter 5, I prefer the film because we learn that Willy Wonka runs a contest for going visit his factory, in image, it's more funny !!!
Whereas in the book, we learn by the newspaper ... it's boring.
And in the book, Charlie seems to have less chance.
I prefer the film because in the film we saw Humpa Loompas.I love Humpa Loompas.Pearhaps it's because nearly all my friends are very small.
For this chapter, I prefer the book because Willy Wonka explains in details the organization of his worldwide lottery. He insists about the prize and the visit that he'll give to the five lucky winners. He will show them all the magie and secrets of his factory. In the film, we only see the headline of the EVENING BULLETIN. We have less information in the film than the book.
I prefer chapter 5 in the film because we see willy wonka and his factory and we see how big and great it is.
In the book Charlie's family learnt Mr Wonka decided to allow five children to visit his factory by reading a newspaper,whereas in the film they learnt it on TV. So Charlie's family is poorer in the book than in the film.I prefer the book because we don't espect him to find a golden!The book more incredible!
To mind, the book is better than the film in chapter 5. I find that the Golden Tickets, in the book, are better introducted than the film. In the book, we get the family's opinion whereas in the film, we only see Charlie. But, in the film, Grandpa Joe is shown as a worker in the chcolate factory by Tim Burton, I believe this is interesting.
In this chapter,I prefer the book because they are more details about the challenge.
I like the challenge because anybody can win and I like it,but rich families are luckier than poor families because they can't afford many chocolate bars.
In the book ,Dahl insists on the fact that :Charliecan win a golden ticket ,whereas ,in the film we see that everyone wants a golden ticket .In the book ,Carlie finds the golden ticket the first time whereas in the film , he finds the golden ticket the third time .
Chapter 5:
I prefer the book because it is more explanatory.It is fabulous that five lucky childr(en are going to visit the mysterious chocolate factory.It's umbelievable that the chocolayte factory didn't open for the last ten years.The other children have much more chance to win than Charlie.For Grandpa Joe mister Willy Wonka is a magician.
I think that the book really, beggins in the chapter five, because it is in this chapter that we learn that five lucky winners, can visit the biggest chocolate factory in the world! but charlie's grandpa said that charlie hasn't got a chance because he has got juste on chocolate bar a years (for his birthday). I think too the capter five is less long that chapter eight or one. Willy Wonka, the confectionnary's genius said that one of five winners can be his heir...of course, I prefer the book because in the film it's a very little passage
In chapter 5, I prefer the book, because we have more details; but in the film, we can see the Oompas Loompas , and that's good!
Enregistrer un commentaire